Abstract
Healthcare organisations increasingly require healthcare professionals to complete e-learning for mandatory training and continuing professional development. This organisationally required e-learning has become embedded within healthcare organisations as a routine approach to delivering workforce education. Despite becoming an established feature of workforce education, many healthcare professionals continue to experience required e-learning as an exercise in organisational compliance rather than a meaningful opportunity for learning. Whilst previous research has largely evaluated the educational effectiveness of e-learning, considerably less attention has been given to how healthcare professionals experience organisationally required e-learning within the realities of clinical practice. Understanding these experiences is essential if organisations are to move beyond simply delivering online training towards creating workplace learning that supports professional practice.
A scoping review was undertaken to examine how healthcare professionals experience organisationally required e-learning. Following PRISMA-ScR guidance, searches of four electronic databases, supplemented by grey literature and citation searching, identified 17 sources that met the inclusion criteria. Data were synthesised using thematic analysis.
Three interconnected themes were identified: the perceived value of e-learning in practice, workplace constraints and engagement, and e-learning design and engagement. Across the literature, healthcare professionals valued e-learning that was clinically relevant, interactive and directly applicable to practice. However, engagement was influenced as much by organisational factors, including heavy workloads, limited protected learning time, competing clinical priorities and organisational expectations, as by the design of the e-learning itself. Consequently, e-learning was frequently experienced as a task to be completed rather than an opportunity for professional development.
The findings suggest that the educational value of organisationally required e-learning is shaped not only by the design of digital resources but also by the organisational conditions in which learning takes place. Improving workplace learning therefore requires attention to both educational design and the organisational environments in which digital learning occurs, ensuring healthcare professionals have protected learning time, organisational support and opportunities to apply learning within clinical practice. For clinical educators, the challenge is not simply to design better e-learning, but to create the organisational conditions that enable digital learning to become meaningful workplace learning.