Logo image
The Authenticity-Efficiency Paradox: How AI-Generated Captions Shape Social Media Engagement
Conference proceeding   Peer reviewed   ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT

The Authenticity-Efficiency Paradox: How AI-Generated Captions Shape Social Media Engagement

Emmanuel Okang Edim, Celestine Iwendi, Zainab Adeyemo, Chukwuemeka Uche,  Vandana Sharma and Adaora Uche Ezennia
Proceedings of 2nd International Conference on Digital Innovations for Sustainable Solutions ICDISS -2026
ICDISS-2026. 2nd International Conference on Digital Innovations for Sustainable Solutions (Faridabad, 20/11/2026–21/11/2026)
09/2026

Abstract

Index Terms—Generative AI, AI-text detection, BERT, social media engagement, TikTok, content provenance, authenticity, human–AI collaboration
Generative AI can scale social-media production, but its synthetic linguistic signature may reduce audience trust. This paper quantifies that trade-off using a two-phase transformer pipeline. A BERT-base-uncased detector, fine-tuned on mixed-domain human and AI text, achieved 93.85% validation accuracy (macro F1 = 0.94, N = 4,274). The detector was then applied to 7,225 de-duplicated TikTok captions from 2025 to estimate a continuous AI-authorship probability, PAI. The pre-specified aggregate test found a small negative relationship between PAI and engagement rate (Pearson r = −0.0467, p < 0.001, 95% CI [−0.070, −0.024]; R 2 = 0.22%). Exploratory rank correlations were weak and directionally mixed: likes decreased (ρ = −0.022, p = 0.062), comments increased (ρ = 0.029, p = 0.014), and shares were unchanged (ρ = 0.013, p = 0.269). The most AI-intensive decile recorded 11.21% mean engagement versus 13.37% for the most human-authentic decile, a 2.16-percentage-point or 16.2% relative gap. We term this observed, non-causal contrast the Authenticity Tax. The results support a hybrid workflow in which AI supplies structure and scale while humans restore voice, emotion, and contextual specificity.
pdf
The Authenticity-Efficiency Paradox: How AI-Generated Captions Shape Social Media Engagement2.49 MB
Accepted Restricted Access CC BY V4.0  — This license enables reusers to distribute, remix, adapt, and build upon the material in any medium or format, so long as attribution is given to the creator.
url
ICDISS-2026View
Event page

Metrics

1 Record Views

Details

Logo image

Usage Policy