Logo image
The principle of parliamentary sovereignty
Journal article   Peer reviewed

The principle of parliamentary sovereignty

John McGarry
Legal Studies, Vol.32(4), pp.577-599
12/2012

Abstract

Law
In this paper, I use Dworkin’s distinction between rules and principles to analyse the doctrine of parliamentary sovereignty. I argue that, inherent in many conceptions of the doctrine, is an assumption that it operates in the conclusive manner of a Dworkinian rule. I then submit that the doctrine actually functions in the flexible way characteristic of a Dworkinian principle. In support of this contention, I argue that Acts of Parliament may be balanced against competing principles or statutes; that they possess the dimension of weight or importance; and that the degree to which they will be adhered in any particular case will be contingent upon the importance attributed to any competing principle or statute. I finish the paper with an evaluation of my arguments and an attempt to anticipate potential counter-arguments.
url
Link to Published VersionView
Published (Version of record)Publisher sites may require subscription to read content

Metrics

30 Record Views

Details

Logo image

Usage Policy