Logo image
Comment on A.-M. Schultz' Socrates and Socrates: 'Looking back to Bring Philosophy Forward'
Journal article   Open access   Peer reviewed

Comment on A.-M. Schultz' Socrates and Socrates: 'Looking back to Bring Philosophy Forward'

Suzanne Stern-Gillet
Proceedings of the Boston Area Colloquium in Ancient Philosophy, Vol.30(1), pp.142-155
2015

Abstract

Emotions Diotima Phaedo Socrates Intellectualism
 Philosophy
The paper, although polemical for the most part, also presents a substantive thesis. The polemical part is directed at the claim that the Platonic Socrates held that philosophy as a practice is to be devoted to the care of self and others, and that the expression of emotion is an important aspect of the philosophic life. To undermine that claim, counter-examples from the autobiographical narrative in the Phaedo and the speeches of Diotima and Alcibiades in the Symposium are brought in. Once analysed at the required depth, those passages show that, on the contrary, Plato's Socrates remains consistently dispassionate both in his life, as he narrates it, and in the views he is made to express in the two dialogues. Rather than promoting self-expression, Socrates never ceased to warn us against misology.

pdf
An Avuncular Socrates.pdfDownloadView
Open Access
url
Link to Published VersionView
Published (Version of record)Publisher sites may require subscription to read content

Metrics

19 File views/ downloads
25 Record Views

Details

Logo image

Usage Policy