Logo image
A systematic literature review of bank failure prediction models
Journal article   Open access   Peer reviewed   PUBLISHED

A systematic literature review of bank failure prediction models

Japheth Jev, Lukman A. Akanbi, Muhammad Bilal, Arun Sukumar, Simeon Babatunde, Hakeem Owolabi and Vasileios Kolovos
Finance Research Open, Vol.2(4), 100186
12/2026

Abstract

Artificial intelligence Bank failures Bank regulation Banking crisis Early Warning System Ensemble AI Banking Machine Learning
Following the Global Financial Crisis of 2008–2009, bank-failure prediction and Early Warning Systems (EWS) have received renewed attention from researchers and banking regulators seeking to identify vulnerabilities in financial institutions before failure occurs. However, the literature employs heterogeneous definitions of bank failure, predictor variables, modelling approaches, prediction horizons, validation designs and performance measures, making comparison and interpretation of reported predictive performance challenging. This systematic literature review identifies, evaluates and synthesises a focused body of post-Global Financial Crisis research on bank-failure prediction models, with particular attention to the methodological characteristics, validation practices and comparative predictive performance of conventional econometric and artificial intelligence/machine learning (AI/ML) approaches. Following a PRISMA-informed study-selection process, a sequentially refined search of the Scopus database identified 23 publications meeting the review criteria, comprising 21 primary empirical studies and two review studies. The narrative synthesis examined model type, operational definition of bank failure, data and predictor variables, prediction horizon, validation design, performance metrics and comparative predictive performance. The findings reveal substantial methodological heterogeneity across the empirical literature. Bank-level financial and accounting variables remain prominent predictors, while broader macroeconomic and non-financial risk factors are less consistently represented. Several studies reported competitive or higher predictive performance for AI/ML approaches relative to conventional econometric models; however, the magnitude and consistency of these differences varied across datasets, failure definitions, prediction horizons, class distributions, evaluation metrics and validation designs. Greater interpretive weight was therefore placed on within-study comparisons conducted under broadly comparable empirical conditions. Overall, the evidence indicates that AI/ML methods can provide incremental predictive value in particular settings but does not establish their universal superiority over conventional econometric approaches. The review further identifies limitations in the treatment of class imbalance, model validation, performance evaluation and model interpretability. These findings support the need for more transparent and methodologically comparable evaluation frameworks and provide directions for future research on robust and regulator-relevant bank-failure Early Warning Systems.
pdf
A systematic literature review of bank failure prediction models2.53 MBDownloadView
Published (Version of record) Open Access CC BY V4.0  — This license enables reusers to distribute, remix, adapt, and build upon the material in any medium or format, so long as attribution is given to the creator.
url
Link to published versionView
Published (Version of record) Open Access Open CC BY V4.0  — This license enables reusers to distribute, remix, adapt, and build upon the material in any medium or format, so long as attribution is given to the creator.

Metrics

3 File views/ downloads
2 Record Views

Details

Logo image

Usage Policy