Abstract
This thesis explores the attitudes of primary school teachers towards the
inclusion of blind students and identifies the factors that influence them.
Although teacher attitudes are widely recognised as a key marker of
successful inclusive education endeavours, little published research
examines attitudes towards blindness within UK primary schools. The
dominant professional approach emphasises individual skills development
through specialist intervention, with comparatively little attention directed
towards the cultural assumptions, structural arrangements and
organisational conditions that shape how teachers understand and respond
to blindness.
A critical realist methodology, drawing on Bhaskar’s stratified ontology and
Pawson and Tilley’s realist evaluation framework, was adopted to move
beyond describing attitudes to explaining the underlying mechanisms that
produce them. Phase 1 employed an exploratory quantitative approach
incorporating measures of explicit attitudes, stereotype content and
behavioural intentions derived from the Theory of Planned Behaviour. The
initial phase also utilised an Implicit Association Test which is the first
application measuring teachers’ implicit attitudes towards blindness in the
UK. Phase 2 built upon the exploratory findings by utilising theory driven
interviews to develop explanatory themes.
Phase 1 revealed that teachers hold broadly positive explicit attitudes
towards inclusion while simultaneously demonstrating moderate to strong
implicit bias. Patterns of paternalistic stereotype content also emerged,
positioning blind people as being warm but less competent. The central
finding of the exploratory phase was that teachers express care and a
commitment to inclusion, yet the content of their attitudes is saturated with
ocular normative assumptions that produce deficit positioning.
Phase 2 identified mechanisms operating across four interconnected levels.
Cultural ocular normativity positions vision as essential to competent
functioning. Structural knowledge exclusion from Initial Teacher Training
creates a preparation vacuum resulting in cultural stereotypes substituting
f or professional knowledge. Individual teachers experience inclusive
tension which is a distinct psychological state where inclusive values meet
structurally induced incapacity. Organisational resource competition narratives
convert individual anxiety into institutional justifications for
exclusive reasoning. These mechanisms, analysed through Beer’s Viable
Systems Model, demonstrates that the system is not failing but functioning
as configured.
This thesis contributes a multi level explanatory model which encourages
the examination of structural conditions before reaching individual level
explanations.