Logo image
The Role of the State in Promoting Economic Social Justice:  An Analysis of the Administrative Period of Umar Ibn Al Khattab (634 to 644 CE)
Dissertation   Open access

The Role of the State in Promoting Economic Social Justice: An Analysis of the Administrative Period of Umar Ibn Al Khattab (634 to 644 CE)

Ahmer Huda
Doctor of Philosophy (PHD), University of Greater Manchester
04/2025

Abstract

This thesis investigates the role of the state in advancing economic and social justice during the administrative period of Umar ibn al-Khattab (634–644 CE). It examines the fiscal, legal, and welfare systems established under his leadership, situating them within the ethical imperatives of Islamic governance and evaluating their wider significance for both historical understanding and contemporary debates on inequality and justice. The study positions Umar’s period as a critical moment in the institutionalisation of Islamic economic thought, where scriptural principles were translated into policies that shaped governance, distribution, and accountability. The research employs a multi-method design, combining historical case studies with textual analysis of Quranic injunctions, Prophetic traditions, and early juristic interpretations, alongside comparative engagement with modern economic theories. This approach facilitates a layered exploration of: (i) the regulation of trade and markets under state supervision; (ii) the development of systematic revenue streams, including Zakat, Jizya, Kharaj, and spoils of war; (iii) the establishment and management of the Bait-al-Maal as the central fiscal institution; and (iv) labour and wage policies, with particular attention to the accountability of governors, judges, and the army. The methodological breadth ensures that the analysis captures both the historical context of Umar’s governance and its resonance with enduring questions of distributive justice. The findings demonstrate three main contributions. First, Umar’s administration operationalised Islamic ethical principles-justice (ʿadl), welfare (maṣlaḥa), and equity through coherent fiscal and administrative reforms. These included the expansion of revenue bases, institutionalised redistribution, and carefully structured welfare allocations. Second, his emphasis on accountability and transparency, including the monitoring of officials’ wealth and the separation of judicial authority from political power, strengthened the trust between state and society. Third, his distributive policies-grounded in Zakat, the prohibition of hoarding, and the rejection of usury-went beyond immediate relief to promote sustainable social cohesion, economic circulation, and investment in human capital. The thesis further highlights the relevance of these measures for contemporary debates on economic justice. By drawing parallels with modern frameworks such as progressive taxation, welfare economics, Rawlsian distributive justice, and Piketty’s critique of wealth inequality, it illustrates how Islamic approaches to circulation, redistribution, and social responsibility align with and enrich global discussions on equitable economic systems. In conclusion, this research makes a dual contribution. To Islamic economic history, it offers a detailed examination of the fiscal and administrative innovations of Umar’s era, situating them within the broader trajectory of Islamic governance. To wider economic discourse, it demonstrates how historically grounded and ethically informed Islamic principles can inform modern strategies for addressing inequality, designing welfare policies, and promoting sustainable economic governance. Together, these insights reaffirm the continuing relevance of Umar ibn al-Khattab’s model as both a subject of historical scholarship and a resource for contemporary policy reflection.
pdf
The Role of the State in Promoting Economic Social Justice: An Analysis of the Administrative Period of Umar Ibn Al Khattab (634 to 644 CE)1.04 MBDownloadView
Open Access In Copyright All Rights Reserved  — This item is protected by copyright and/or related rights. You are free to use this Item in any way that is permitted by the copyright and related rights legislation (such as any Fair Dealing allowances allowed by copyright law). For other uses you need to obtain permission from the rights-holder(s).

Metrics

1 Record Views

Details

Logo image

Usage Policy