Logo image
Algorithmic Authority and the Crisis of Leadership Legitimacy: Reconfiguring Authority, Trust, and Accountability in AI-Driven Organisations
Book chapter   Peer reviewed   PUBLISHED

Algorithmic Authority and the Crisis of Leadership Legitimacy: Reconfiguring Authority, Trust, and Accountability in AI-Driven Organisations

Bilal Zaghmout and Christian Harrison
Leadership and Digital Transformation, pp.276-304
Routledge Studies in Leadership and Leadership Development, Routledge
29/10/2026

Abstract

Algorithmic decision-making Digital transformation Leadership legitimacy AI governance Organisational accountability Artificial intelligence Algorithmic authority
The growing deployment of artificial intelligence (AI) technologies in the domain of organisational decision-making practices is disrupting long-established principles of leadership and its legitimacy. Existing studies tend to focus almost exclusively on the interplay between leadership and the adoption of new digital technologies but overlook important structural changes associated with the increasing role of AI. To address this gap, this chapter introduces the concept of algorithmic authority to show how AI-based decision systems assume the role of authoritative actors in organisational governance contexts, thus changing the balance of power, the grounds of legitimacy of human leadership, and its modes of accountability. Grounded in literature on leadership, organisational legitimacy, and AI governance, the chapter provides a framework that allows for analysing the socio-technical processes through which the rise of algorithmic authority transforms the distribution of power in organisations, undermines epistemic trust in human leaders, and produces a fragmented regime of accountability within hybrid human-AI decision architectures. It further proposes that such a socio-technical turn creates a crisis of leadership legitimacy by questioning conventional beliefs about visibility, moral agency, and personal responsibility. To address such challenges, this chapter suggests that in the age of AI, the concept of leadership legitimacy should undergo a fundamental transformation and become rooted in the socio-technical governance of hybrid decision systems.
pdf
Algorithmic Authority and the Crisis of Leadership Legitimacy446.38 kB
Accepted Embargoed Access, Embargo ends: 29/04/2028 CC BY-NC-ND V4.0  — This license enables reusers to copy and distribute the material in any medium or format in unadapted form only, for noncommercial purposes only, and only if attribution is given to the creator.
url
Link to published versionView
Published (Version of record) Publisher sites will require purchase to access content Restricted In Copyright All Rights Reserved  — This item is protected by copyright and/or related rights. You are free to use this Item in any way that is permitted by the copyright and related rights legislation (such as any Fair Dealing allowances allowed by copyright law). For other uses you need to obtain permission from the rights-holder(s).

Metrics

3 Record Views

Details

Logo image

Usage Policy